Get instant study help

In the regular Stable Match- ing problem, we assumed that participants prefer to be matched over bei

Tutors ProblemsPosted On:2023-10-29 12:38:33Viewed:614

In the regular Stable Match- ing problem, we assumed that participants prefer to be matched over being unmatched. In this question, we will remove this condition, as it may not always be a realistic assumption. We modify the original Stable Matching problem so that the participants now have a list of preferences which can potentially be incomplete (i.e., the list may not include every possible participant from the opposite set of participants). As before, a participant prefers being matched with someone on their list over being unmatched. But a participant prefers being unmatched over being matched with someone not on their list. In this modification, the notion of a stable matching is a matching (not-necessarily perfect) in which: • There is no pair (x,y) where x and y are not matched to each other, but they prefer each other over their current situation (i.e., their current match or being unmatched). • There is no matched participant who prefers being unmatched over being matched with their current match. Is it true that if a participant is unmatched in one stable matching, then they are unmatched in all stable matchings (i.e., is it true that there is no hope for some people)? Why?

Best Answer

Tutor

Tutor

Solved by verified expert

Last updated on:2023-10-29 12:38:33

It is not the case that if a participant is unmatched in one stable matching that they will also be unmatched in the other stable matchings if they take part in more than one stable matching. This is due to the fact that the preferences of the participants can shift over time, and the preferences of the participants can determine which stable matching strategy yields the best results. As a result, it is possible for a participant to be unmatched in one stable matching, but if the preferences of the participants shift, it is possible that they will be matched in another stable matching.

Step-by-step explanation
  • Stable matching is an important problem in computer science and economics, and it is used to match participants in a variety of scenarios, such as job placement and matching students to medical residencies. Stable matching is also a term that refers to the process of matching participants in various scenarios. In the traditional approach to the stable matching problem, it is assumed that the participants have complete lists of preferences, which means they are aware of the order in which they would prefer to be matched with each and every possible person. On the other hand, in many situations that take place in the real world, the participants might not have complete preference lists, which would mean that they might not know their order of preference for all of the possible matches.

  • It is permissible for the participants in the updated version of the stable matching problem to have preference lists that are missing some items. This indicates that each participant has the option of adding certain potential matches to their list or removing them from their consideration altogether. As was the case before, a participant would prefer not to be unmatched and instead be matched with someone on their list. On the other hand, a participant would rather not be matched at all than be paired with someone who is not on their list.

  • The purpose of the modified stable matching problem is to find a stable matching, which means that there is no pair (x,y) in which x and y are not matched to each other but they prefer each other over their current situation. In other words, the goal of the problem is to find a stable matching (i.e., their current match or being unmatched). In addition, there should not be a single participant who has a match but would rather not have a match than be matched with the person who is their current match.

  • It is not always the case, taking into consideration the updated version of the stable matching problem, that if a participant is unmatched in one stable matching, then they are unmatched in all stable matchings. This is because the stable matching problem has been modified. This is due to the fact that the preferences of the participants can shift over time, and the preferences of the participants can determine which stable matching strategy yields the best results. As a result, it is possible for a participant to be unmatched in one stable matching, but if the preferences of the participants shift, it is possible that they will be matched in another stable matching.

  • Take, as an illustration, a problem of stable matching in which there are three participants labeled A, B, and C. A has only included B and C on their preference list, leaving out all other options. B has only included A and C on their preference list, leaving out all other options. C has only included A and B on their preference list, leaving out everything else. A is paired with B during the preliminary stages of the stable matching, while C remains unmatched. On the other hand, if the preferences of the participants were to shift, there is a chance that C could be paired with A, given that C might now choose to be matched with A rather than remaining unmatched.

  • To summarize, it is not always the case that a participant will be unmatched in all stable matchings if they are unmatched in one stable matching. If they are unmatched in one stable matching, it does not mean that they will be unmatched in all stable matchings. This is due to the fact that the preferences of the participants can shift over time, and the preferences of the participants can determine which stable matching strategy yields the best results. As a result, it is possible for a participant to be unmatched in one stable matching, but if the preferences of the participants shift, it is possible that they will be matched in another stable matching.


Previous:Failed RECAPTCHA check.是怎么回事?

Next:What do the time (s) and speed (mph) curves of the dynamic stress test (DST) for automotive operatin

Get instant study help

Post Reply

Contact Us

qrcode

扫码联系微信客服 享一对一做题服务